Press reviews
James Phelan: show review ★★★★★
“An expert at seemingly impossible tricks. And he’s funny too”

“A Perfect Night of Wonder”

280 sold-out theatres a year. Five smash-hit international tours. The best-selling magic show at the Edinburgh Fringe. Member of the Inner Magic Circle with Gold Star and author of How to do Magic. It’s easy to see why reviewers call James “British magic at its finest”, “a masterclass” and “a performer at the top of his game”. These are his reviews, read them in full.
Across 34 ★★★★★ and ★★★★ reviews, the pages that follow collect the notices from The Guardian, The Times, HELLO!, The Sun, The List, Scottish Field and the Edinburgh Fringe press, with every quote as it was published.
34 ★★★★★ and ★★★★ reviews
James Phelan reviews from the press
Edinburgh Live★★★★★“This man IS magic.”
The Dreamer · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 15 August 2024 · Robyn Bell
“will stun the whole family”
“it’s hard not to believe in magic after seeing the show.”
“I was often left scratching my head after he managed to guess which card an audience member had and more impressively when he hypnotised some of those in attendance.”
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“I went to see hypnotist James Phelan at the Fringe and now believe in magic”Edinburgh Live, 15 August 2024
StageSideUK★★★★★“it was honestly mind-bending from start to finish”
The Man Who Was Magic · The Majestic Theatre, Darlington · 21 November 2026 · Jonathan Harper
“A five-star evening and an easy recommendation if you get the chance to see it”
“I was in awe”
A ★★★★★ review of the Darlington Majestic Theatre performance.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“The Man Who Was Magic Review: A Mind-Bending Five-Star Night at The Majestic Theatre”StageSideUK, 21 November 2026
Henley Herald★★★★★“The show left you smiling from the hilarity and wondering how he did all that.”
The Greatest Magician · Kenton Theatre, Henley-on-Thames · 1 November 2022 · The Editor
“Disbelief, flabbergasted, stunned… with some hilarious one liners thrown in”
“James really wowed the audience with his entertaining show.”
Card tricks, a random word from Wikipedia, hypnotism and a needle trick that is “not for the faint-hearted”.
Lisa in the Theatre★★★★★“It’s just pure, mystical magical wizardry.”
The Man Who Was Magic · Edinburgh Fringe · Edinburgh Fringe 2025 · Lisa in the Theatre
“This is modern, intelligent, mind-blowing magic.”
“A stunning display of theatrical magic”
Rain on stage as the audience walks in, live jazz, and telepathy that silences the room.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review: James Phelan, The Man Who Was Magic, Edinburgh Festival Fringe 2025”Lisa in the Theatre, Edinburgh Fringe 2025
World Magic Review★★★★★
“seeing the universal effect of this particular trick was absolutely mind blowing”
The Dreamer, Live · Edinburgh Fringe · 17 August 2024 · Hannah S
“The Dreamer is the place to be.”
“He’s the perfect performer to celebrate the achievability of the impossible.”
A ★★★★★ review of The Dreamer, the show rooted in his parents’ IVF journey and the idea of following your dreams.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: The Dreamer, Live”World Magic Review, 17 August 2024
Voice Magazine★★★★★“It all tied together as a great show”
Troublemaker · Gilded Balloon Teviot, Edinburgh · 4 August 2019 · Emrys Green
“The magic was great, the delivery was very relaxed, and there was the right level of pzaz.”
“everyone certainly seemed to be having a very good time.”
A review of Troublemaker, James’ debut show at the Edinburgh Fringe.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“A big laugh but the focus was magic, and some stunning tricks were delivered.”Voice Magazine, 4 August 2019
One4Review★★★★★
“his show is one you won’t forget”
Showman · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 25 August 2026 · Gavin
“This “Showman” is a total natural”
“the balance between trickery and humour is exceptional.”
Hypnosis, mentalism and humour in the “magical circus vibe” of The Beauty at the Circus Hub.
What the Redhead Said★★★★★“It’s a show that will have you baffled and amazed in equal measure.”
The Greatest Magician · Camberley Theatre · The Greatest Magician tour · Donna Wishart
“An astonishing, enigmatic show that left pretty much all of us dumbfounded.”
“we loved every minute”
A family night out at Camberley Theatre, with stories of Paul Daniels and James’ childhood.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“The Greatest Magician Live Tour Review”What the Redhead Said, The Greatest Magician tour
LouReviews★★★★★“You’ll be talking about it for days.”
The Man Who Was Magic · Adelphi Theatre, London · 24 September 2025 · Helen Cox (guest reviewer)
“This show is a fantastic night out.”
“A very funny and likeable performer”
A roaming camera zooms in on the tricks so the whole theatre can see.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan, The Man Who Was Magic (Adelphi)”LouReviews, 24 September 2025
LondonTheatre1★★★★★“bursting with personality! Highly recommended”
Showman · Underbelly Boulevard, London · 21 June 2026 · John Groves
“a showcase of a performer at the top of his game.”
“the irresistible charisma of a performer who knows exactly how to work a room!”
A ★★★★★ review of Showman in London’s West End, with a warning to front-row sitters that they may be taking part.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: Showman, Underbelly Boulevard”LondonTheatre1, 21 June 2026
Suzzi’s Spotlight★★★★★“By the finale, the tent is full of wide eyes, open mouths, and pure delight.”
Showman · Edinburgh Fringe · 27 August 2026 · Suzzi Hirst
“A show that proves the simplest moments can be the most magical.”
“He’s a natural entertainer”
Glitz, glamour and gentle moments of wonder with the younger members of the audience.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: Showman, Review, Edinburgh Fringe Festival 2026”Suzzi’s Spotlight, 27 August 2026
Edinburgh Festivals Magazine★★★★★“James Phelan’s performance is not to be missed.”
The Dreamer, Live · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · August 2024 · George Young
“The Dreamer-Live is a powerhouse performance.”
“leave the audience in awe”
A ★★★★★ review of The Dreamer in the big top at Underbelly’s Circus Hub, praising how he improvises with audience members.
LondonTheatre1★★★★★“this is British magic at its finest”
The Man Who Was Magic · Adelphi Theatre, London · September 2025 · Chris Omaweng
“understated yet utterly magnificent from beginning to end”
“a gentle style of humour combined with friendly banter made for a very entertaining evening”
A ★★★★★ review of the West End staging at the Adelphi Theatre.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“The Man Who Was Magic, Adelphi Theatre: Review”LondonTheatre1, September 2025
A Young(ish) Perspective★★★★★“Phelan is on top of his game”
Showman · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 25 August 2026
“you do not take your eyes off of him”
“His ability in magic is brilliant.”
Card predictions, the psychology behind them, and mentalism through two lightly hypnotised volunteers.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“A Masterclass in Magic, Mind Control and all Things Mystical”A Young(ish) Perspective, 25 August 2026
Suzzi’s Spotlight★★★★★“will leave you feeling amazed and spellbound with wonder for days.”
The Dreamer, Live · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 16 August 2024 · Suzzi Hirst
“an experience not to be missed”
“an enchanting display of heartwarming and touching magic.”
A ★★★★★ review of The Dreamer at the 2024 Edinburgh Fringe, which praises it as a masterfully crafted production.
The Guardian★★★★★“I have not a scooby how such tricks are accomplished. The mind reels.”
Showman · Underbelly Boulevard, London · 22 June 2026 · Brian Logan
“it’s all amazing!”
“a welcome injection of wonder”
Brian Logan’s review of Showman at Underbelly Boulevard, which he calls a “hugely entertaining show”.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: Showman review: an amazing pick’n’mix of telepathy and magic”The Guardian, 22 June 2026
West End Best Friend★★★★★“this is stage magic of a high order”
The Man Who Was Magic · Adelphi Theatre, London · 24 September 2025 · Chris Abbott
“Definitely a young magician to watch”
“Phelan is an engaging and communicative performer, a natural and quick-witted comedian”
“He instantly engages with the audience”
A ★★★★ review of the West End staging at the Adelphi Theatre, ahead of the UK tour.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review: JAMES PHELAN - THE MAN WHO WAS MAGIC, Adelphi Theatre - Tour”West End Best Friend, 24 September 2025
The List★★★★★“He’s storing everything up to blow our minds further down the track.”
The Dreamer · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 16 August 2024 · Kelly Apter
“And what a joy it is to watch it executed so masterfully.”
“he’s certainly a spokesman for making the impossible possible.”
A review of The Dreamer at the Edinburgh Fringe, the show built around James’ childhood dream of becoming a magician.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“A beautifully executed show from a magician with an unceasing capacity for wonder”The List, 16 August 2024
BroadwayWorld★★★★★“dazzles with skill, moves with sincerity”
The Man Who Was Magic · Adelphi Theatre, London · 29 September 2025 · Christiana Rose
“a magician with both flair and heart”
“Phelan’s gift for connecting with his audience is undeniable.”
The West End review followed the show’s one-night Adelphi run after Edinburgh, from the Rat Pack opening to the gold and red lanterns.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review: The Man Who Was Magic, Adelphi Theatre”BroadwayWorld, 29 September 2025
Scottish Field★★★★★“Oozing with charisma from the get-go”
Showman · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2026 · Millie Pace
“Dazzling, old-school magic is back.”
“this is a fun-filled, extraordinarily impressive hour worth your time”
A sold-out 500-seat circus tent, an hour of magic, live jazz and plenty of comedy.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Edinburgh Fringe Reviews: Showman, James Phelan”Scottish Field, Edinburgh Fringe 2026
The List★★★★★“leaves everyone dumbfounded”
Troublemaker · Gilded Balloon Teviot, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2019 · Arusa Qureshi
“one to watch in the world of magic”
“In this fast-paced show, Phelan barely skips a beat”
James’ debut Edinburgh Fringe show: mentalism, card magic and a grand finale with an iPhone and a bucket of water.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Rising magical performer successfully leaves audiences dumbfounded”The List, Edinburgh Fringe 2019
World Magic Review★★★★★
“certainly one to see this year”
The Man Who Was Magic · McEwan Hall, Edinburgh · 2 August 2025
“The hypnotism and magic performed are all done with exceptional skill.”
“With his quick wit and charm Phelan has an easy chemistry with everyone who he invites to get involved in the show.”
A review of The Man Who Was Magic in Edinburgh’s McEwan Hall at the 2025 Fringe.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: The Man Who Was Magic”World Magic Review, 2 August 2025
EdinburghGuide★★★★★
“it’s no wonder he is selling out the show every night.”
Showman · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2026 · Millie Pace
“leaves you laughing one minute and then leaning forward in your seat and whispering ‘how did he do that!?’ the next.”
“He is instantly likeable, and clearly has a way with people.”
Card tricks, mentalism with audience volunteers and a highlight moment with a young boy on stage.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan ‘Showman’, Underbelly Circus Hub, Review”EdinburghGuide, Edinburgh Fringe 2026
Scottish Field★★★★★“A must see this year.”
The Dreamer · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2024 · Fiona Tenneb
“we were blown away by the tricks”
“bringing gasps from the audience”
Reviewed with three children aged 12, 13 and 14, who each left smiling.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Fringe Review: The Dreamer”Scottish Field, Edinburgh Fringe 2024
North West End UK★★★★★
“a visually stunning magic show”
The Man Who Was Magic · Underbelly Bristo Square, Edinburgh · 8 August 2025 · Saira Kunjuvalappil
“I was captivated from the moment I entered the theatre.”
“it was a thoroughly enjoyable evening of laughter, amazement, and just the right level of intrigue.”
A review of The Man Who Was Magic at the 2025 Edinburgh Fringe.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: The Man Who Was Magic, Underbelly Bristo Square”North West End UK, 8 August 2025
A Young(ish) Perspective★★★★★“the audience were rapt”
The Dreamer, Live · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 5 August 2024 · Claire McArthur
“stunned by some well performed and seemingly inexplicable magic”
“an informative as well as entertaining experience”
A sold-out first night, with card predictions and the psychology behind why people pick the cards they do.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review: The Dreamer, Live”A Young(ish) Perspective, 5 August 2024
Everything Theatre★★★★★“You’re on the edge of your seat”
Showman · Underbelly Boulevard, London · 26 June 2026 · Rosie Wood
“It is one of the most ambitious feats of hypnotism conceivable”
“the tricks themselves are undoubtedly incredible.”
Rated “Excellent” on Everything Theatre’s scale (4 out of 5 in the page’s rating data).
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“An eventful evening of hypnotism, comic vulnerability and incredible mind-reading”Everything Theatre, 26 June 2026
Bouquets & Brickbats★★★★★
“features several WTF moments that have me shaking my head in disbelief”
The Man Who Was Magic · McEwan Hall at Underbelly, Bristo Square, Edinburgh · 6 August 2025 · Philip Caveney
“some of them are quite bewildering”
“The Man Who was Magic is an accomplished production and Phelan is a relaxed performer who takes the audience into his confidence”
A ★★★★ review of the Edinburgh Fringe staging at McEwan Hall.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan: The Man Who Was Magic”Bouquets & Brickbats, 6 August 2025
The Real Chrisparkle★★★★★
“I just watched, agog, and in awe.”
The Dreamer, Live · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 17 August 2024 · Chris Sparkle
“leave you totally spellbound”
“I haven’t a clue as to how he did any of it”
Card predictions, a whole-audience imagination experiment and a very special kind of mind control.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews: The Dreamer, Live”The Real Chrisparkle, 17 August 2024
EdinburghGuide★★★★★
“it is a real joy to be in the presence of old school magic”
The Man Who Was Magic · McEwan Hall at Underbelly, Edinburgh · 12 August 2025 · Angela Milton
“James Phelan knows how to put on a show”
“this is a fun-filled entertaining show.”
A review of The Man Who Was Magic at the 2025 Edinburgh Fringe.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“James Phelan, The Man Who was Magic (2025), McEwan Hall at Underbelly, Bristo Square, Review”EdinburghGuide, 12 August 2025
Bookmarks and Stages★★★★★
“No idea how he did it.”
The Dreamer · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 9 August 2024 · Louise
“What a joy this is.”
“so beautiful and meaningful, that really touched my heart”
A personal show for adults and children alike, with a finale the reviewer found beautiful and meaningful.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review of The Dreamer, performed by James Phelan”Bookmarks and Stages, 9 August 2024
One4Review★★★★★
“an absolutely mind-blowing finale involving mobile phones.”
Troublemaker · Gilded Balloon, Edinburgh · 10 August 2019 · Geoff
“stage presence by the bucket load”
“He is definitely an up and coming performer and I’m sure he will go far.”
A review of Troublemaker at the 2019 Edinburgh Fringe, with a finale involving mobile phones.
Bookmarks and Stages★★★★★
“This isn’t just magic!”
Showman · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 19 August 2026 · Louise
“James Phelan is a showman and one to watch!”
“leaving the audience in awe”
Live jazz, a ring, fire and a glass, and a trick built around a young volunteer’s dreams.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“Review of magician James Phelan, Showman: Entertaining Family Magic Show at Underbelly’s Circus Hub on the Meadows”Bookmarks and Stages, 19 August 2026
The Quintessential Review★★★★★“send the audience away happy and amazed”
The Dreamer, Live · Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 11 August 2024 · Will Quinn
“producing wow moments”
“You can sense his utter delight in every synchronised gasp of amazement and round of applause.”
A stage in the round in ‘The Beauty’ tent, with James holding court from the centre.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“EdFringe Review: The Dreamer, Live”The Quintessential Review, 11 August 2024
The Times“astonished viewers jammed the BBC switchboard”
Showman · Edinburgh Fringe 2026 · 30 July 2026
“an expert at seemingly impossible tricks. And he’s funny too”
A Times pick of Showman from the Edinburgh Fringe 2026 festival coverage.
Read the full articleOriginal headline“Eva Perón, Joni Mitchell: the Fringe is celebrating women this year”The Times, 30 July 2026
HELLO!“we laughed from beginning to end”
The Man Who Was Magic · Adelphi Theatre, London · 7 October 2025 · Andrea Caamano, Digital Content Director
“the show was just pure joy”
“I would do it all over again in a heartbeat!”
“If you're looking for the perfect date night, James Phelan's latest magic show is exactly that.”
The Sun“fun, captivating and shocking”
The Dreamer · Live performance in London, ahead of the Edinburgh Fringe · 30 July 2024 · Ellie Henman, Bizarre Editor
“If you are heading to the Fringe, it is well worth checking him out.”
From the Bizarre column, after a live performance in London before The Dreamer opened at the Edinburgh Fringe.
Theatre4Everyone
“We entered as sceptics and departed as believers.”
The Man Who Was Magic · The Majestic Theatre, Darlington · 21 November 2026 · andybram69
“we left not merely entertained but utterly astonished”
“this was a masterclass in magical entertainment”
A review of the Darlington Majestic Theatre performance.
Read the full reviewOriginal headline“The Man Who Was Magic: Simply Spellbinding!”Theatre4Everyone, 21 November 2026
Britain’s Got Talent“No other explanation other than magic.”
Simon Cowell, Britain’s Got Talent
“He was extraordinary”
Amanda Holden, Britain’s Got Talent
“Outstanding”
KSI, Britain’s Got Talent